# LIB2-155 — The charge-magnitude ledger retains two exposed proton-separation defects

- class: CLAIM · review_state: PUBLISHED · house_tier: not yet assigned
- labels as printed: math_status NOT_PRINTED · attachment NOT_PRINTED · scorecard tier word none (PDF p.132)
- basis: {"pdf_sha256_prefix": "b64ddcd9e16a6dcd", "release": "Rev33.1_S369"}

## Statement

Under the banked baseline ruling, the proton-separation estimate Sp(9B) is 1.29 times the world value and Sp(8B) is 2.60 times the world value; correct signs and counts do not close the magnitude sector.

## Caution

The strong sign/count record does not derive charge magnitudes or justify choosing a more favourable baseline after comparison.

## Primary source

Paper 9, §9, Charge-magnitude defects, PDF p.137: "Charge signs and counts are derived; charge magnitudes wander: Sp (9 B) × 1.29, Sp (8 B) × 2.60 under the baseline ruling."

## Machine

- url: /library-v2/LIB2-155/
- content_sha256: eac25a1b4beac5273157b388db70baf667881c594300a9b30c770fe5fb654e80
- candidate_ids: C2-072

## Freshness

- BUILD_STAMP S371a · 2026-09-26T22:53Z · master 01d1a5873ede42f5 · cut 9dcc6ce9a8ee3e02
- Declared volatile fields (R36): BUILD_STAMP